Waste Is Not Just a Sanitation Problem: It Is a Governance Problem

By |2026-09-30T11:55:37+02:00October 6th 2026|Good Governance|

Better waste management is not only about collecting more waste. It is about how cities organise responsibility, coordinate services and work with the informal actors already keeping systems running. Accra shows why governance can be just as important as infrastructure.

When waste piles up on city streets, the failure is easy to see. Its causes are often much less visible. Urban waste is often discussed as a technical challenge: collection routes, recycling rates, landfill capacity, trucks, transfer stations, and treatment technologies. When waste accumulates, the assumed response is often more equipment, better logistics, or another round of infrastructure investment.

Those investments matter. But persistent waste failures in rapidly growing cities suggest that the visible problem on the street is often shaped by something less visible: how institutions divide responsibility, coordinate services, include – or exclude – informal actors, and respond to the people who use the system every day.

Waste is therefore more than an environmental service. It is also a window into how cities are governed.

Beyond Collection

Accra, Ghana, illustrates why technical intervention alone cannot explain – or solve – urban waste challenges. A participatory assessment of its municipal solid waste system found collection coverage of about 75 per cent and waste capture of 53 per cent. These figures came after roughly two decades of formal private-sector participation in the sector. In other words, bringing private companies into the system had not, by itself, resolved its underlying problems.

Research from Ghana explains why. A 2022 assessment of public-private partnership governance found weaknesses in accountability, transparency, competitiveness, and value for money, as well as disconnects between national policy and local implementation. Earlier work in Accra also found that informal service providers were already making substantial contributions to collection and resource recovery while remaining only partially integrated into the formal system.

Together, these findings change the way we need to think about waste-management failure. A city can expand collection and involve private providers while still leaving crucial responsibilities fragmented across municipal authorities, contractors, communities, and informal workers. The key question is not simply: how much waste is being collected? It is also: does the system make clear who is responsible when collection fails – and can that failure actually be corrected?  Vehicles, contracts, and facilities may expand capacity; they do not on their own determine who coordinates the system, whose knowledge informs planning, or who must act when parts of it fail.

Recognising The Informal System

Urban waste systems are frequently described as though municipal authorities and contracted providers make up the ‘real’ system, while informal collectors operate somewhere outside it. In practice, this boundary is far less clear – and often, the formal system works partly because informal networks fill its gaps.

In Accra, informal service providers have long filled gaps left by formal collection, particularly in underserved areas. Research documenting efforts to integrate them found that greater recognition and collaboration could improve collection and recycling while reducing municipal costs. No new technology created their contribution. What changed was their relationship with the formal system. Once governance arrangements recognised and involved them, their work could contribute more effectively to the service as a whole.

This exposes a central contradiction in many urban waste systems: cities depend on informal networks to maintain basic functionality while those same networks may lack legal recognition, institutional support, reliable data channels, or a meaningful voice in planning.

The problem is therefore bigger than inefficiency: it is a problem of accountability. When waste accumulates, municipal authorities can point to financing constraints, contractors to operational limits, residents to uneven service, and informal actors to exclusion from the rules that shape the sector. Each explanation may be partly true, but when responsibility is spread across so many actors without clear coordination, no one is fully able – or required – to fix the system as a whole.

When Imported Models Meet Local Reality

Part of the problem is what might be called a structural transplant: when cities import waste-management models without importing the institutional conditions that made those models work elsewhere. A system designed around predictable financing, enforceable regulation, and clearly assigned responsibilities may perform very differently where those conditions do not exist.

Modern collection fleets may arrive without dependable maintenance budgets. Sophisticated service contracts may exceed the municipality’s capacity to monitor them. Source-separation schemes can be introduced before credible public communication and feedback channels exist. Formalisation, meanwhile, can proceed without recognising the actors who already recover materials and serve neighbourhoods that formal systems struggle to reach.

The lesson is not that technology does not matter. It is that technology never operates in isolation. The performance of a truck, recycling facility, or digital collection platform ultimately depends on institutions capable of financing, coordinating, regulating, and maintaining the service over time – and adapting it when conditions change. A technically sound solution can therefore still fail if the institutions around it cannot support it.

Waste Policy Is Also Urban Policy

Unmanaged waste contaminates soil and water, blocks drainage, increases flood risk, damages public space, and creates serious health burdens. But waste policy also shapes who benefits from the city – and who carries its burdens. Decisions about collection, disposal, and recycling determine which neighbourhoods receive reliable services, where environmental burdens accumulate, which livelihoods are recognised, and whose priorities influence public investment.

For local governments, better waste management therefore requires more than improving the physical chain from collection to disposal. Institutional capacity, coordination, transparency, public participation, and the relationship between formal and informal providers are not additional concerns. They are part of the infrastructure that allows the service to function.

This also means measuring success differently. Tonnage collected and equipment delivered still matter, but they tell only part of the story. A functioning urban waste system should also make responsibility traceable when service breaks down, provide dependable coverage to underserved communities, recognise informal contributions fairly, and retain enough institutional flexibility to respond when conditions change.

Waste tells a story about how a city works. When it accumulates, the failure is visible on the street, but the causes often reach much deeper. Treating waste as a governance problem does not replace engineering. It creates the conditions for engineering to work.

Rama Nassif
Latest posts by Rama Nassif (see all)